Table of Contents >> Show >> Hide
- How BHG Tested Curtains (And Why That Matters)
- Quick Picks: BHG-Tested Curtains at a Glance
- The Best Curtains by Type (BHG-Tested Highlights)
- Best Light-Filtering Curtains: IKEA RITVA
- Another Light-Filtering Favorite: Pottery Barn Belgian Flax Linen
- Best Sheer Curtains: Quince Cotton Sheer Curtain Set
- Another Sheer Option: Better Homes & Gardens Sheer Tie-Top Panel
- Best Room-Darkening Curtains: Quince Cotton Slub Room-Darkening Curtain
- Best Blackout Curtains: Better Homes & Gardens Textured Chenille Blackout Panel
- Other Tested-and-Loved Mentions: Satin Texture + Luxe Linen
- What to Know Before You Buy Curtains
- 1) Measure Like You Mean It (Because Curtains Don’t “Wing It” Well)
- 2) Hang Them “High and Wide” for the Designer Effect
- 3) Choose Your Light Level (Sheer vs. Light-Filtering vs. Room-Darkening vs. Blackout)
- 4) Fabric, Texture, and the Great Wrinkle Debate
- 5) Header Styles: The “Top” That Changes Everything
- 6) Comfort and Energy: Curtains as “Soft Insulation”
- Common Curtain Mistakes (And How to Avoid Them)
- Your Questions, Answered
- Real-World Curtain Experiences: What You’ll Notice After Living With Them (Extra Notes)
Curtains are basically the eyebrows of your windows: they frame everything, set the mood, andif you choose badlymake the whole room look a little surprised.
The good news? Better Homes & Gardens (BHG) did the try-on-haul so you don’t have to, testing popular curtain styles at home and grading them on what actually
matters in real life: how they filter (or block) light, how they drape, how they feel, how smoothly they open and close, and whether they look like a bargain
in the best wayor the “why is this shiny?” way.
This guide breaks down BHG’s top-tested curtain picks (from sheer to blackout), then zooms out with practical, design-pro advice on measuring, hanging, and choosing
the right fabric and header style. If you want a room that feels finishedwithout accidentally buying curtains that are either too skimpy, too short, or too “hotel
conference room”you’re in the right place.
How BHG Tested Curtains (And Why That Matters)
“Best curtains” can’t just mean “pretty in the product photo.” BHG approached testing the way most of us live: curtains opened in the morning, closed at night,
yanked sideways when someone wants a nap, and stared at daily like they’re part of the family. Their evaluations focused on effectiveness (light and privacy),
design (how the fabric hangs and looks in a room), quality (stitching, material feel, hardware compatibility), and value (what you get for the price).
They also consulted an interior designer for shopping guidancebecause sometimes you need a professional to confirm that yes, hanging curtains higher really does
make your ceiling look taller (and no, your eyes are not playing tricks on you).
Quick Picks: BHG-Tested Curtains at a Glance
| Category | BHG Standout | Best For | Heads-Up |
|---|---|---|---|
| Light Filtering | IKEA RITVA Curtains | Bright rooms that still need privacy | Limited color selection |
| Light Filtering (Upgrade) | Pottery Barn Belgian Flax Linen | Classic linen look, tall windows | Wrinkles easily; panels can run narrow |
| Sheer | Quince Cotton Sheer Curtain Set | Airy softness + daytime privacy | Limited colors; typically dry-clean care |
| Sheer (Budget) | Better Homes & Gardens Sheer Tie-Top Panel | Easy, breezy style on a tight budget | Not for serious light control |
| Room Darkening | Quince Cotton Slub Room-Darkening Curtain | Reducing glare while keeping a relaxed look | Often sold per panel (cost adds up) |
| Blackout | Better Homes & Gardens Textured Chenille Blackout Panel | Bedrooms, media rooms, maximum privacy | Color range can be limited |
Now let’s get into the detailsbecause “blackout” can mean anything from “pitch-black cave” to “dimly lit vampire brunch,” depending on fabric, lining, and how you hang it.
The Best Curtains by Type (BHG-Tested Highlights)
Best Light-Filtering Curtains: IKEA RITVA
If you want your room to feel bright and alivebut not like you’re on display in a fishbowllight-filtering curtains are the sweet spot. BHG’s standout in this
category was IKEA’s RITVA, praised for letting in plenty of light while still maintaining privacy. The fabric has a linen-like texture that pleats nicely, giving
a more elevated look than the price suggests.
- Best for: Living rooms, kitchens, and anywhere you want glow without glare.
- Why it works: Balanced light diffusion + a crisp drape that looks “intentional.”
- Keep in mind: Color options may be limited, so you’re choosing more for function and texture than a huge palette.
Another Light-Filtering Favorite: Pottery Barn Belgian Flax Linen
Linen curtains have a particular superpower: they make a room feel finished without feeling fussy. BHG liked Pottery Barn’s Belgian flax linen panels for their
soft, timeless look and how beautifully they cascade. They’re also a strong option for taller windows, where longer lengths can be harder to find in standard lines.
- Best for: Primary living spaces, dining rooms, and anyone chasing that relaxed-luxury vibe.
- Why it works: The fabric looks rich, filters light softly, and feels substantial.
- Keep in mind: Linen wrinklesoften dramatically, like it’s auditioning for a period drama. If you hate wrinkles, plan to steam.
Best Sheer Curtains: Quince Cotton Sheer Curtain Set
Sheers are for people who want sunlight to enter the room politelyno harsh spotlighting, no squinting through your morning coffee. BHG’s top sheer pick from Quince
was noted for its modern crosshatch texture and a “substantial yet airy” feel. In testing, the panels looked high quality and were nearly wrinkle-free right out of
the package (which is basically the curtain equivalent of arriving early with snacks).
- Best for: Layering under heavier curtains, brightening bedrooms, softening harsh daylight.
- Why it works: Texture adds style even in solid colors; fabric still feels “real,” not flimsy.
- Keep in mind: Color selection may be limited and care may lean toward dry-clean instructions.
Another Sheer Option: Better Homes & Gardens Sheer Tie-Top Panel
Want sheers that don’t take themselves too seriously? BHG also highlighted a Better Homes & Gardens sheer tie-top panel sold through a big-box retailer.
Tie-tops read casual and charminggreat if you want “effortless” rather than “formal.” Think airy privacy, gentle movement, and a little visual personality.
- Best for: Guest rooms, rental refreshes, or a quick style win.
- Why it works: Easy to install, easy on the wallet, and still looks intentional.
- Keep in mind: Tie-tops can be less convenient for frequent opening/closing than rings or grommets.
Best Room-Darkening Curtains: Quince Cotton Slub Room-Darkening Curtain
Room-darkening curtains are the “I want less sun, not a full eclipse” option. BHG’s pick from Quince blocked nearly all sunlight in testing, leaving a soft ambient
glow instead of full darkness. The textured cotton cross-weave gives that natural, organic look, while the blackout-style lining helps with privacy and can make
a space feel noticeably cooler in hot months.
- Best for: South- or west-facing rooms, nurseries, and TV rooms where glare is the enemy.
- Why it works: Strong light reduction without the heavy feel of thick drapery.
- Keep in mind: Often priced per panelbudget accordingly for wide windows.
Best Blackout Curtains: Better Homes & Gardens Textured Chenille Blackout Panel
If your goal is “bedroom cave, but make it stylish,” BHG’s best blackout pick was a textured chenille panel from Better Homes & Gardens.
The big win here is that it looks softer and more elevated than many utilitarian blackout options. In BHG’s testing summary, it blocked the vast majority of light
(and delivered the privacy you want when it’s dark outside and your lamp is on).
- Best for: Bedrooms, shift-work sleepers, media rooms, and street-facing windows.
- Why it works: Plush chenille texture reads cozy and premium while still doing the job.
- Keep in mind: Even excellent blackout panels can leak light at the sides if your rod is too narrow or your panels aren’t wide enough.
Runner-up idea (also tested by BHG): Pinch-pleat blackout curtains can look more tailored and “custom.” BHG noted a pinch-pleat option that
noticeably darkened the room, though some edge light can still sneak in if the panels don’t wrap the window.
Other Tested-and-Loved Mentions: Satin Texture + Luxe Linen
BHG also tested (and liked) a light-filtering pebbled satin-style panel for its soft texture and high-end look created by hidden tabsthough it may need layering
if you want more privacy or less light. Another strong performer was a European flax linen panel praised for its drape, privacy, and elevated finish, with the bonus
of a wider color range (at a higher price point).
What to Know Before You Buy Curtains
1) Measure Like You Mean It (Because Curtains Don’t “Wing It” Well)
Most curtain regrets come from two things: the wrong length, or panels that are too narrow. Designers consistently recommend fuller curtainsgenerally aiming for
total panel width around 2 to 2.5 times the window width for a rich look. If you’re going extra luxe, more width creates deeper waves and a
higher-end drape.
For hanging height, you’ll commonly see advice to mount rods a few inches above the window frameoften 4 to 8 inchesor even closer to the ceiling
to visually stretch the room. And yes, it works. Your ceiling doesn’t get taller, but your room starts acting like it did.
Fast measurement checklist
- Decide rod placement first: higher for height illusion; wider for more light when open.
- Rod width: plan for extra width beyond the window so panels can sit mostly off-glass when open.
- Total panel width: target 2x to 2.5x your window width (or rod span) for fullness.
- Length: measure from where the curtain will hang down to your desired endpoint.
2) Hang Them “High and Wide” for the Designer Effect
If you only steal one professional trick, steal this one. Hanging curtains higher and extending the rod wider than the window makes windows look larger,
ceilings look taller, and the whole room look more polished. Some guides suggest rods that extend roughly 8–12 inches beyond the window width, while other design
sources recommend going even wider when the wall space allows for a dramatic “bigger window” illusion.
3) Choose Your Light Level (Sheer vs. Light-Filtering vs. Room-Darkening vs. Blackout)
- Sheer curtains: soften daylight and provide daytime privacy, but they won’t block night visibility if lights are on inside.
- Light-filtering curtains: diffuse sunlight while offering better privacy and a more substantial look than sheers.
- Room-darkening curtains: reduce glare and dim the room significantlygreat for TV rooms and bedrooms that don’t need total darkness.
- Blackout curtains: designed for maximum light blocking and privacy, but results vary based on fabric, lining, and installation.
One reality check: “blackout” on a label doesn’t always mean “movie-theater dark.” Independent testing has found that plenty of curtains marketed as blackout
fall short of true blackout conditions. If you’re sensitive to light, consider theater-grade options, layered treatments, or adding a shade underneath.
4) Fabric, Texture, and the Great Wrinkle Debate
Fabric isn’t just a style decisionit changes how curtains hang, how they wear over time, and how much maintenance they require.
- Linen: airy, timeless, and casually elegantalso famously wrinkly. Great drape, but plan for steaming.
- Cotton: versatile, approachable, and usually easier care. Texture varies from crisp to slubby to gauzy.
- Velvet/chenille: rich, cozy, and excellent for light control; adds warmth and drama fast.
- Polyester blends: durable and often used in blackout linings; typically more wrinkle-resistant and budget-friendly.
Also: washing can change everything. Some designers warn that machine-washing certain fabrics (especially linen) can cause noticeable shrinkageso always check care
instructions before assuming your curtains can take a spin cycle like a bath towel.
5) Header Styles: The “Top” That Changes Everything
The header (how curtains attach to the rod) affects how they slide, how formal they look, and how much light leaks at the top.
- Rod pocket: classic and simple, but can be harder to open/close daily because the fabric grips the rod.
- Grommet: modern, smooth-gliding, and great for daily useexpect subtle light gaps near the rings.
- Back tab: creates soft waves with hidden hardware; a clean look that feels more tailored than rod pocket.
- Pinch pleat: structured and formal; often looks custom and pairs well with rings or tracks.
- Multi-way tops: flexible options that can work with back tabs, rod pockets, or rings depending on your hardware.
If you open and close curtains every day, prioritize smooth operation (grommets, rings, or back tabs). If they’re mainly decorative, you can pick purely based on style.
6) Comfort and Energy: Curtains as “Soft Insulation”
Thick curtains and lined drapes can help reduce drafts and heat gain near windows, especially when paired with well-fitting shades. For larger energy gains,
insulated shades (like cellular shades) are often cited as top performersbut layering them with curtains gives you both comfort and style.
Common Curtain Mistakes (And How to Avoid Them)
- Too narrow: Panels look skimpy and don’t close properly. Fix it by adding more panels or choosing wider ones.
- Wrong length: Too short can shrink the room visually; too long can collect dust or become a tripping hazard.
- Rod placed too low: Makes ceilings feel shorter. Raise it to stretch the room upward.
- Style over function: A pretty sheer in a bedroom might look dreamyuntil the sunrise has other plans.
Your Questions, Answered
How long should curtains be?
A popular designer look is curtains that “kiss” the floorjust barely touching. For a more dramatic, formal vibe, a small puddle can work (but it’s not ideal
for high-traffic homes or rooms with pets and kids). For practical spaces, slightly skimming above the floor helps keep hems cleaner.
How many panels do I need?
Start with the goal of 2 to 2.5 times the window width in total curtain fabric. For a standard window, that often means two panelsunless your panels are narrow,
your window is wide, or you want a very full, luxe look (in which case, add more panels).
How do I get blackout curtains to actually block more light?
Choose truly lined blackout panels, then focus on installation: hang the rod wider, ensure enough total fabric width, and consider wraparound rods or layering with
a shade underneath. Many “light leaks” are really “hardware and coverage” issuesnot fabric failures.
Real-World Curtain Experiences: What You’ll Notice After Living With Them (Extra Notes)
Buying curtains is one thing. Living with curtainsopening them, closing them, cleaning them, noticing how they behave in sun and shadowis where the truth shows up.
Here are common, real-life experiences people run into after installing BHG-style “best picks” (and how to make them work for you), written like the kind of advice
you’d get from a friend who’s already made the mistakes and is now trying to save you from repeating them.
Week 1: The “Wow, This Looks Expensive” Moment. This is when you realize texture matters more than you thought. Light-filtering curtains with a linen-like
weave instantly make a room feel layeredeven if you didn’t change anything else. People often report that the biggest upgrade isn’t the color; it’s the way the fabric
breaks up light. Sheers with subtle texture can make plain windows feel soft and intentional, like the room finally put on real shoes instead of slippers.
Week 2: The Slide Test (A.K.A. “Why Is This So Hard to Open?”). Curtains can be gorgeous and still annoy you daily. Rod pockets tend to grip rods and
can feel stubborn, especially with heavier fabric. This is where grommets, rings, and back tabs win hearts. If you plan to adjust curtains every day for privacy or
sun control, you’ll appreciate anything that glides smoothly. People who switch from rod-pocket to rings often describe it like upgrading from dragging a suitcase to
rolling one: same destination, much less frustration.
Week 3: The Light-Leak Reality Check. Even strong blackout curtains may not give perfect darkness if the panels don’t extend far enough past the window
or if the rod is too narrow. In bedrooms, a common “aha” moment is noticing that the fabric is doing its job, but light is sneaking in at the top corners or sides.
The fix is usually boringbut effective: add more width (extra panels), mount the rod wider, or use a wraparound style. Some households also end up layering: a simple
blackout shade underneath plus curtains on top creates the best sleep setup without sacrificing style.
Week 4: Maintenance and the Mystery of Wrinkles. Linen looks amazing… and then it wrinkles because you looked at it. That’s not a flaw so much as a
personality trait. Owners often learn a simple routine: steam the front-facing folds, ignore the rest, and call it “relaxed.” For cotton and polyester blends, the
experience tends to be easierless wrinkling, faster dusting, and fewer “I should really steam these” thoughts haunting you from across the room.
Month 2 and Beyond: Comfort You Didn’t Expect. People who install room-darkening or blackout curtains often notice an unexpected side benefit: the room
can feel calmer and slightly more temperature-stable, especially in sunny windows. You may find yourself turning on the TV without fighting glare, taking afternoon naps
that don’t feel like you’re sleeping on stage, or simply enjoying a softer ambiance. The main takeaway from long-term curtain living is that the best curtains aren’t
just “pretty panels.” They’re tools: for sleep, privacy, light control, mood, and even making your space feel more grown-up with minimal effort.
The biggest lesson: Curtains work best when you treat them like a system. Fabric + lining + width + rod placement all team up. If one element is off,
you’ll feel it. But when everything clicks, your windows look larger, your room looks taller, and your home feels finishedlike it finally remembered to put on a belt.